 | William B. Webster – President (Pro tem) 1876-August 1, 1876-May 31, 1877 |
 | Henry Clark – President June 16, 1876-April 1877 |
 | John J. Thomas – President 1882 |
 | Henry O. Norton – President 1883-1886, 1890 |
 | Otto J. Guckert -President 1887-1888 |
 | William Edelman – President 1888 |
 | George Rinnah Wells – President 1889 |
 | Morris Heagy – President 1890-1891 |
 | Francis H. Stevens – President 1892-1893 |
 | Joseph Hermes – President 1893-1895 |
 | William Edelman – President 1895-1897 |
  | Isaac Mortimer Fleet 1858-1948 – President 1896-1899 |
 | Paul Peter Guckert 1864-1944 – President 1901-1902 |
 | James Elmer. Maxwell 1875-1937 – President 1902-1903 |
 | Gustov Harder (1859-1934) – President 1905-1907 |
  | Joel Martin Benson (1864-1945) – President 1907-1909 |
 | George W. Turner (1859-1941) – President 1909-1911 |
 | George McNabney (1855-1945) – President 1911-1912 – Village Clerk 1917-1934 |
 | Albert August Oltman (1873-1944) – (Interim Pres) Nov 1912-1913 – Trustee 1910-1911, 1912-1913, 1919 |
 | Ethelbert E. Holton (1864-1942) – President 1913-1914, 1914-1915 – Trustee 1907-1908, 1910-1911, 1912-1913 |
 | George W. Turner (1859-1941) – President 1916 |
 | Ethelbert E. Holton – President 1917-1919 |
 | Charles E. Moore – President 1919-1921,1921-1922,1923-1924,1925-1926 |
 | Ethelbert E. Holton – President 1927-1928 |
 | Charles E. Moore – President 1929-1930 |
 | Jacob Hermes (Protem 1930) – President 1931-1932 |
 | Albert Oltman – President 1933-1934 |
 | S.J. Shepard – President 1935-1936 |
 | George Wilken 1883-1963 – President 1937-1940 |
 | George Kline – President 1941-1944 |
 | Dick D. Howell 1914-1994 – President 1945-1948 |
 | George McNeal 1905-1987 – Interim President 1948-1949 |
 | John M. Gillespie 1918-1986 – President 1949-1952 |
 | Dick D. Howell 1914-1994 – President 1953-1956, 1957-1960 |
 | James Quinn 1916-1999 – President 1961-1964 |
 | John K. Sansale 1928-2007 – President 1965-1976 |
 | James Severtsguard 1928-1923 – President 1977-1980 – Trustee 1967-1970 |
 | Robert O. Schaeffer |
 | Scott Newburg |
| |